Part A
Primal
Without modern civilization, it is only natural for these people to act this way. It is a very primal thing for humans to look for cause and effect, and this is what works for them, it is all they know. Without a reasonable breakdown of why something is the way it is, it is only rational for people to create it themselves.
Ignorance
Ignorance is strength, and if the rituals prove to be working in the eyes of the 'higher-ups', it must work. People want answers to their problems, and since the rituals are accepted by their entire society, it is understandable that they all follow through, even if it is miserable and painful. "The more powerful individuals in the society have several shrines in their houses and, in fact, the opulence of a house is often referred to in terms of the number of such ritual centers it possesses. Most houses are of wattle and daub construction, but the shrine rooms of the more wealthy are walled with stone. Poorer families imitate the rich by applying pottery plaques to their shrine walls."
Worship
Again, people need an explanation for their illnesses and woes. If that means worshiping a shrine with charms, so be it. The magic-men appear to be god-like in the way they are perceived by the civilization, who "... write them (ingredients for potions) down in an ancient and secret language; [t]his writing is understood only by the medicine men and by the herbalists."
Economy
If something costs something, then it has value. The 'hospital' in this civilization requires substantial gifts to give their ritual healing, so people assume it has merit. "No matter how ill the supplicant or how grave the emergency, the guardians of many temples will not admit a client if he cannot give a rich gift to the custodian. Even after one has gained and survived the ceremonies, the guardians will not permit the neophyte to leave until he makes still another gift."
Education
The way people are manipulated is to keep them uneducated, and to portray deep respect for the 'trained' medicine-men who run the latipso, or the 'listeners' who merely act as a psychologist. They are deemed special because they have been trained to do their acts. "[The] ceremonies involve not only the [medicine-men] but a permanent group of vestal maidens who move sedately about the temple chambers (latipso; hospital) in distinctive costume and headdress."
Part B
1. I feel the words I used are not so different than how I would describe religion, the medical field and things of those nature in America. In churches they sometimes persuade people to donate money, whether it be for a good or bad cause; and medical insurance is in many ways similar to the tribe described in the article, you have to pay beforehand and afterward in order to get treatment - which to me seems preposterous in our society - we deserve universal healthcare.
2. I kept this in mind as I read the article, no I don't think I was biased at all. All people are ignorant to some extent. Replace the terms latipso, nacerima etc. and change the context, I would have the same opinions I have about America.
3. I guess I would remove the word primal and replace it with fear in the context of our culture. A lot of our mannerisms and the ways people present their opinions derive from that.
4. Yes I think it is possible to avoid cultural bias with enough education and experience. This is important because, if you are being an ethnocentric, it only leads to judgements, not facts.
Credit for Part A. Part B missing.
ReplyDeleteI apologize, it completely skipped my mind for some reason.
DeleteOh, nice dig on the Universal Healthcare issue!
ReplyDeleteAs far as you choice of words, you may be confusing "bias" with "accurate". Your words may indeed be accurate based upon (a) Miner's description and (b) our culturally specific definition of the terms, but that doesn't mean that they are unbiased. The word "primal" especially carries with the concept of a more primative, less-advanced culture. The only thing that word tells us is that you consider this culture less advanced than your own. It doesn't advance our really understanding of this culture.
You have a greater confidence in our ability to rid ourselves of bias than I do. It's too ingrained in our human nature to do away with completely. But at least we can watch out for it if we know we are susceptible to it.
Good post.